We have a long way to go before EVs are perfected. Most require hefty price premiums over conventionally powered vehicles, and many entailed glitches in electric and software functions during early test drives. Others have poor interior craftsmanship and chintzy quality. Then there is the question of driving range, which is really about the lack of a national electric charging network for drivers.
Still, the excitement reflects something real. I have written about cars, SUVs, trucks, and motorcycles for nearly two decades, and I have never seen a more exciting, challenging, and surprising time in the automotive industry. Consumers ultimately will be the biggest winners of the whole electrification process because the vehicles just keep getting better.
Here is a look at the five best purely electric vehicles I drove this year.
1. Mercedes EQS
The Mercedes-Benz S Class was the single best car I drove this year. Its electric equivalent, the $US102,310 ($143,570) EQS, lacks a little of the extreme sumptuousness and perfect mechanical and technological calibrations of this executive sedan. But the EV’s engaging touchscreen command centre (available in the top-of-the-line EQS 580 4Matic) and powerful quick-drive quality offer a healthy glimpse of how the best electric sedans of the future will feel and perform.
Compared with its competitors, the EQS falls on the higher side of the range-anxiety debate: Its 485-mile (780km) range bests the Tesla Model S’s 412 miles and Porsche Taycan’s sub-300 miles. It charges to 80 per cent of capacity in 31 minutes with DC fast charging, about the going rate these days.
It is not the fastest vehicle of the lot – the line-topping EQS 580 4Matic gets 516 hp (380Kw) and 631 pound-feet (856 Nm) of torque. It goes from zero to 60 mph (96.6km/h) in 4.1 seconds on its four-wheel-drive chassis, which is slower than the highest versions of the Taycan and Model S. But in a car with interior accoutrements and technology that far exceeds those models, the EQS owner will hardly notice – or care about – the difference.
2. Rivian R1T
This was perhaps the most hyped vehicle of the year, with newbie electric vehicle maker Rivian topping out at $US100 billion in value when it went public in November. I and some other reporters can take some of the blame for this: I called the R1T the vehicle I most wanted to drive in 2021.
The global electric truck market size is projected to reach $US1.9 billion by 2027, according to Allied Market Research, up from $US422.5 million in 2019. What Tesla did for electric cars – force them into mainstream consideration – has yet to be done for electric trucks.
Rivian’s R1T is the first contender. Aimed at the triathlete mountain-climbing “gorp-core” (good ol’ raisins and peanuts) Silicon Valley tech-bro, the $US74,075 pickup counts many novel inventions to its name. They include a pass-through storage space beneath the truck bed and a factory-installed, on-board air compressor for emergencies in the wilderness. Plus, it has 314-mile range and looks at least good enough to support the company’s claim that it’s the “Patagonia of trucks”.
I drove it for a few days on and off roads near Breckenridge, Colorado. The R1T’s software is still buggy – and it’s not as rugged as similarly priced standbys from Jeep and Land Rover – but it’s an exciting first offer from a company we are sure to see plenty of.
3. Audi RS e-tron GT
The $US139,900 Audi RS e-tron GT is built on the same electric platform as the Porsche Taycan, with the same two-speed automatic transmission from its parent company, Volkswagen. Both exceed the Tesla Model S in looks, build quality, interior craftsmanship and infotainment intuitiveness. So, it’s important to note how they differ, especially because the Taycan, which came to market a year before the e-tron, is a strong option for electric vehicle fanatics. Otherwise, you’re just picking a hood badge you like, right?
To my eye, the e-tron GT looks better than the Taycan. It is more svelte, with a sleeker roofline – the lowest of any Audi, apart from the R8 – and an aggressive stance enhanced by 21-inch set wheels that are cut like blades and bright LED headlights traced in blue. A panoramic glass roof comes standard on the base GT, while higher-tuned, more expensive RS versions come standard with a carbon fibre ceiling. (The glass roof on those is optional.)
The most notable new element in the e-tron GT is the Tic Tac-box-sized “shifter”that moves the car from neutral to reverse or drive. (The Taycan has one, too.) Otherwise, the interior has a minimal quality, with fewer computers and touchscreens than in the Taycan and warm wood-veneer options throughout.
As for performance, the 637-horsepower e-tron GT has a top speed of 155 mph and a zero-to-60-mph sprint of 3.1 seconds. Under relaxed driving, it has a range of 232 miles on one charge. According to Audi, it will charge from 5 per cent to 80 per cent on a 270kW charger in 22.5 minutes. The $US150,900 Taycan Turbo boasts 670 horsepower, a 161 mph top speed, and a zero-to-60 mph sprint in three seconds flat. At best, it has a range of 212 miles.
So, they’re close. Many consumers will choose according to prior brand loyalties. But the Audi e-tron proves that electric sport sedans will be just as engaging and efficient to use as their internal combustion-powered cousins. As it’s the shiny new thing I drove this year, I give it the edge.
4. BMW iX
This one was critical for BMW to get right. The first electric SUV from the Bavarian brand, it – along with the i4 – is the lynchpin for BMW’s target of a tenfold increase in BEV sales from 2020 to 2025, which would represent 15 per cent of the sales mix, or 450,000 units in total, according to Bloomberg Intelligence.
As I said in my review after driving it through the Alps outside Munich, the $US83,200 rig is not exciting to drive, and it lacks the styling cues of the BMW’s X6M, one of my all-time favourite SUVs. But with seating for five and 300-plus miles of driving range, it offers a well-built, thoughtfully appointed cabin and decent handling for its spacious size.
My favourite part was the simplicity of the high-quality, calming cabin and excellent new infotainment interface. Frameless doors, a panoramic glass sunroof, the open-pore wooden dashboard, crystal-cut buttons, and a scrolling “shifter” all felt warmly modern and not, as sometimes happens, cold and robotic.
5. Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo
Electric trucks and other truly function-focused electric rigs are coming, but an exceptional electric station wagon is already available. The $US90,900 Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo combines the proven power and well-made German fabrication of the Taycan with the additional space and practicality of a hatchback wagon.
The entry-level Taycan Cross Turismo has 469-horsepower of performance packed underneath its body, plus the four drive modes on two “gears” – one for strong power under lower speeds, the other for sustained efficiency at high speeds – and the range of the regular Taycan. Acceleration is silky smooth, going from zero to 60 mph in 4.8 seconds, with a top speed of 136 mph.
Its outback-ready options make this all-wheel-drive wagon really shine. The Offroad Design Package ($US1780) raises it 10mm above normal ride height (that’s a total of 30mm higher than the Taycan sedan, a whopping inch) and gives it additional protection panels along the bottom of the front, sides, and wheel arches, great for crawling along dusty river bottoms and scruff.
What’s more, it adds two cubic feet (56 litres) of load capacity in the rear – up to nearly 16 cubic feet, from 14.3 cubic feet in the regular Taycan. All told, the Taycan Cross Turismo has 42.8 cubic feet of storage space in the back when the rear seats are folded flat.
It’s enough to make anyone want to jump in and head out to explore. The fact that it’s a well-made electric vehicle that’s truly viable for daily life is the icing on the cake.